$5.7 Billion! Apple Patent Infringement Case Sets New Record for U.S. Jury Damages Award.
2026-09-27

On September 25, a jury in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California returned a verdict in Taction Technology’s patent infringement case against Apple, finding that the Taptic Engine used in multiple iPhone and Apple Watch models infringed two U.S. patents held by Taction and awarding Apple to pay $5.7 billion in damages—the highest damages verdict ever returned by a U.S. jury in a patent infringement case.

The case began in April 2021, when Taction filed a patent infringement lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California, alleging that the Taptic Engine used in multiple iPhone and Apple Watch products infringed its U.S. Patents No. 10,659,885 and No. 10,820,117. Both patents relate to systems and methods for damped electromagnetic-driven planar motion vibration for audio-frequency vibration, covering electromagnetic actuators that allow users to perceive vibration through touch as well as vibration-related technologies.

After the lawsuit was filed, Apple filed four inter partes review (IPR) petitions with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office challenging the validity of the claims of the two patents at issue, but none was instituted. In 2023, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California granted summary judgment, finding that Apple did not infringe. In 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit vacated that judgment and remanded the case for retrial. After the case returned to the district court, the jury found that some of the haptic feedback technology used by Apple fell within the scope of Taction’s two U.S. patents and ultimately returned a verdict of infringement and $5.7 billion in damages. The jury also found that Apple’s infringement was not willful.

In a statement, Apple said that its Taptic Engine technology is fundamentally different from the technology described in the Taction patents at issue, that it does not accept the verdict, and that it will appeal. Therefore, the $5.7 billion currently remains the damages amount assessed by the jury, and ultimate liability and the final amount remain subject to subsequent judicial proceedings.

Taction was founded in 2014 and mainly engages in the research and development of haptic technology and related hardware products. Its Transporter series haptic vibration modules are used in headphones, VR/AR, gaming devices, wearables, and medical rehabilitation devices, among other fields, and the company previously signed a manufacturing agreement with Foxconn to mass-produce Transporter 4.0 haptic modules. Company founder James Biggs is also an inventor of the patents at issue. In addition to the United States, the related technology also has patent filings in Europe and China.

This is not the first time Apple has been involved in a patent dispute over haptic technology. Previously, Immersion sued Apple over haptic technology used in the iPhone, Apple Watch, and MacBook, and the parties later reached a settlement, with the specific settlement amount not disclosed. In the Chinese market, Apple has also been involved in multiple patent disputes in related technology fields in recent years. Among them, Shenzhen Shizun Technology previously had a patent dispute with Apple over voice coil motor technology used for optical image stabilization. Two recent judgments by the Supreme People’s Court on disputes over the validity of related patents did not support Apple’s claims that the patents were invalid; the related patent infringement case has also been heard by the Shanghai Intellectual Property Court. Previously, in the final instance of China IWNComm’s patent infringement lawsuit against Apple, the Supreme People’s Court upheld a judgment ordering Apple to pay RMB 143 million (approximately US$20 million), marking the highest enforceable damages award against Apple made by a Chinese court to date.